Three sentence movie reviews: The Goodbye Girl

Part of the Ruby Oliver Film Festival.

There was a lot to like about this movie and it has aged quite well.*  I also appreciated how it incorporated many things that could  have gone off the rails,** but never did and it says a lot that the movie is 111 minutes of mostly fighting, but still very fun to watch. However, I found Marsha Mason’s voice grating (unfortunately) and has an uncanny resemblance to someone in my life, so that was incredibly distracting.

Cost:  free from library
Where watched: at home.

Poster from: http://www.impawards.com/1977/goodbye_girl.html

*Especially considering there’s a subplot with a gay Richard III, which manages to be funny and not offensive, at least in my mind.  Other people can feel free to weigh in about this.
**For instance, Quinn Cummings as Lucy McFadden could have gone the way of grating, abrasive child, but instead she managed to perfectly walk the line between world-weary and innocent.  Also, there’s something inherently creepy about random dude moving into an apartment with a little girl living there and the movie managed to not venture into that territory.  Plus, I could have completely become judgmental of Paula McFadden’s quick attachments with (and subsequent dumpings by) men, but for all her grating voice, she managed to charm we away from that line of thinking.

4 thoughts on “Three sentence movie reviews: The Goodbye Girl”

  1. I have not seen this movie. I always seems to start my three sentence movie review comments in that same way. Sorry to be so repetitive.

  2. As usual, this is an excellent review. I am sorry to say that my comments cannot be called the same. Alas, I am petering out of good comments.

  3. I just looked it up on IMDB and I feel so bad for Marsha Mason in the cover picture there because she looks like a really well put together 50 and she was probably 34 when they filmed the movie. Yikes! I'm glad her voice didn't ruin the movie for you. That's the kind of thing where once I notice it, I can't stop noticing it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.